PC MAGIK LAB
▷
Menu
EP 05

Nemotron 3 Nano spends 76% of its output thinking, and 2 of 6 pages broke

nvidia/nemotron-3-nano

Same model, same prompt, same rig. 3 runs with nothing added, 3 with one Karpathy rules file.

nvidia/nemotron-3-nano

Ranges overlap (counted effects)

Effects count CSS/JS constructs, not visual quality.

Explore all 6 runs ↓

Repeated ranges

BARE · n=35–8
KARPATHY · n=36–12
nvidia/nemotron-3-nano bare live output
BARENO RULES, NO EXTRAS
0:59 min:stime
5,851output tokens
77.5%thinking
162lines of code

Effort requested: medium; received: on · differs from requested effort · source: metrics.json. Effort is not comparable across models.

nvidia/nemotron-3-nano karpathy live output
KARPATHYONE RULES FILE
0:42 min:stime
4,057output tokens
75.6%thinking
122lines of code

Effort requested: medium; received: on · differs from requested effort · source: metrics.json. Effort is not comparable across models.

Every run. Every result.

BARE

NO RULES, NO EXTRAS · n=3

Run 1

5effects
0:46 min:stime
4,209output tokens
76.2%thinking
91.64tok/s
114lines of code

Effort requested: medium; received: on · differs from requested effort · source: metrics.json. Effort is not comparable across models.

nemotron-3-nano_bare_r1

Run 2

8effects
0:59 min:stime
5,851output tokens
77.5%thinking
98.91tok/s
162lines of code

Effort requested: medium; received: on · differs from requested effort · source: metrics.json. Effort is not comparable across models.

nemotron-3-nano_bare_r2

Run 3

8effects
0:37 min:stime
3,672output tokens
53.2%thinking
99.43tok/s
212lines of code

Effort requested: medium; received: on · differs from requested effort · source: metrics.json. Effort is not comparable across models.

nemotron-3-nano_bare_r3

KARPATHY

ONE RULES FILE · n=3

Run 1

6effects
0:36 min:stime
4,032output tokens
68.9%thinking
111.19tok/s
161lines of code

Effort requested: medium; received: on · differs from requested effort · source: metrics.json. Effort is not comparable across models.

nemotron-3-nano_karpathy_r1

Run 2

12effects
0:47 min:stime
4,407output tokens
57.4%thinking
93.03tok/s
188lines of code

Effort requested: medium; received: on · differs from requested effort · source: metrics.json. Effort is not comparable across models.

nemotron-3-nano_karpathy_r2

Run 3

6effects
0:42 min:stime
4,057output tokens
75.6%thinking
96.27tok/s
122lines of code

Effort requested: medium; received: on · differs from requested effort · source: metrics.json. Effort is not comparable across models.

nemotron-3-nano_karpathy_r3

output = thinking + final code. Lines of code show the page size the model chose, not the cost of equivalent work.

How to reproduce

Settings recorded for these runs. Multiple values show differences between runs. Effort is requested, not necessarily received; it is not comparable across models. Hover over quantization, K/V cache or engine values for their sources.

nvidia/nemotron-3-nano
Run settings by model
ModelQuantizationContext windowK/V cachemax_tokensEngineHarnessEffort requested
nvidia/nemotron-3-nanoQ3_K_L262,144K f16 / V f16 (LM Studio default)131,072[email protected]pi 0.85.1medium

Watch the experiment.

Watch episode ↗

REPRODUCE THE EXPERIMENT

One prompt.
All the evidence.

Compare runs within the same model. Inspect the shared prompt, settings and raw measurements in the repository.